Fighting Back: Tips and Tactics for Getting a CPS Case Dismissed

6 min


man in black shirt sitting beside woman in white shirt

The Child Protective Services (CPS) is an integral part of our society, working tirelessly to ensure the safety and well-being of children. However, there are instances when innocent families find themselves entangled in a CPS case due to false allegations of child abuse or neglect. In such situations, understanding how to get a CPS case dismissed becomes critical.

This article offers a comprehensive guide on navigating CPS cases, the key steps to securing dismissal, and the vital role of cooperation and legal assistance in this process.

Understanding the CPS

Child protective service is a state government agency responsible for investigating reports of child neglect or domestic violence and abuse. Depending on the state you reside in, it may operate under a different name like the Department of Social Services, Department of Family Services, or Department of Youth and Family Services.

In some rare cases, suspected child abuse might result in taking child custody, and putting the young child in foster care.

The Role of CPS in Your Family

CPS usually collaborates with state and local services to shield children from potential harm. Their mandate includes investigating all reports of child abuse or neglect, and they possess the power to remove a child from the home if there is substantial evidence to support the abuse.

A complaint can be lodged by anyone – a neighbor, a teacher, or even another family member. Child protective service is required to delve into it. As they delve deeper into your family dynamics, they can either let the child stay in the home or initiate steps to remove the child. Remember, this is not a personal affront against you. CPS’s main concern is the child’s welfare. It is essential to maintain your poise during this period.

Identifying Abuse or Neglect

Abuse or neglect definitions vary by state law. Typically, any form of physical, emotional, or sexual abuse a child suffers during his or her life falls under CPS scrutiny. Acts that put the child at risk or pose significant harm to the child’s health are also considered abuse in some jurisdictions.

Neglect, on the other hand, is usually characterized as the failure of a parent or guardian to provide sufficient child care, including:

  1. Inability to provide necessary food, housing, or medical care to the child
  2. Unavailability of a caregiver for your young child when you are unable to look after them
  3. Failure to enroll your child in school (applicable in half the states and DC)
  4. Neglecting to provide necessary additional care for special-needs children

Who Could Have Filed the Report Against You?

Everyone in Texas is legally bound to report any cases of child abuse or neglect they become aware of. Certain professionals like teachers, doctors, and nurses must report within two days of learning about a child’s abuse or neglect. Non-compliance is considered a felony. This drives people to report potential cases of abuse or neglect, even when the underlying evidence may be insufficient.

These reports are filed anonymously, so it is unlikely that you will learn who accused you. The rationale for maintaining the anonymity of these reporters is to protect them from any potential retaliatory actions you might take if you discovered who reported you as a potential child abuser or neglecter.

What Does a CPS Caseworker Look For During an Investigation?

The primary goal of a CPS investigation is to determine if there is anything in your home that could potentially harm your child. If there is no such risk, the investigation should be promptly concluded, and any allegations of abuse or neglect should be dismissed. You will be notified by CPS about the conclusion of the investigation into you, your child, or your family.

In cases where a CPS social worker identifies a condition in your home that could pose a danger to your child, but you show readiness and capability to take preventive actions, the investigation is likely to be concluded as soon as the issue is rectified.

Assessing the Safety Level of Your Home

During an investigation, CPS considers several factors to determine whether your home is safe enough for your child. They examine the current risks in your home that could harm your child, determine if your child is currently at risk, and if there was an incident that harmed your child in the past and is unlikely to recur. The severity of the harm is also considered.

If your child was injured due to a non-accidental cause, CPS might opt to have your child removed from your home. Keep in mind that the individuals you invite into your home could also pose a risk to your child. If you have drug users visiting, their paraphernalia could pose a significant injury risk if left out for your child to access.

Court Proceedings for a CPS Case

If CPS initiates a lawsuit, you will be summoned to family court. At this point, to get your CPS case dismissed, you must gather information and evidence to substantiate your claims.

It is crucial to attend CPS hearings with a lawyer who is well-versed in Texas family law. This ensures you are best placed to respond to queries and present evidence without being defensive.

After your court appearance, you will be given a calendar of dates and times for future court appearances. It is crucial to record all future court dates to continue meeting your commitments. Missing any court dates related to a CPS case is not permitted. Make arrangements in advance to secure your attendance.

How Does a CPS Case Initiate?

A CPS case kicks off with the receipt of a child abuse or neglect report. The report details the child’s situation, conditions in their home, the extent of their injuries, and information about other children in the same environment.

If the report involves severe physical injury or sexual abuse, it is usually handed over to the police. For less severe cases, CPS assesses whether the report is reasonable and requires further investigation. If the allegations do not constitute neglect or have no basis, CPS may reject the report.

However, if the report provides enough reason to believe that the reported facts likely constitute abuse, CPS may initiate its investigation. The urgency of the report and state laws determine the commencement of the investigation, typically:

  • Within 24-48 hours in cases of immediate danger; or
  • Within 30-90 days if there is no immediate threat.

What to Expect During a CPS Case

When embroiled in a CPS case, it’s essential to know what to expect:

Respectful Communication: Every interaction with a CPS social worker or CPS investigator should be respectful, as anything you say can be used against you in court

Importance of Cooperation: Cooperating with CPS is crucial as it can help address the issues noted in the report and prevent the escalation of allegations against you.

Child Interview: CPS caseworkers have the authority to interview the child without parental consent

Confidentiality of the Reporter: The identity of the individual who reported the abuse or neglect will remain confidential

Steps to Get a CPS Case Dismissed

While it’s essential to have a competent legal professional by your side, here are some steps you can take to hasten the dismissal of a CPS case.

1. Stay Calm

Maintaining a calm demeanor throughout the process is paramount. Any display of anger or hostility might give CPS more reason to scrutinize you.

2. Understand the Allegations

Knowing the specifics of the report against you can help you prepare an effective defense.

3. Understand the Potential Outcomes

The outcomes of a CPS investigation can range from the case being closed without intervention to the child being removed from the home.

4. Consult with a Legal Professional

Having a competent legal professional offer guidance and advice can be incredibly beneficial, particularly if the case escalates to court.

5. Prepare for Court

If the case proceeds to court hearing, having a lawyer assist you is essential. Mistakes at this point could jeopardize your ability to reunite with your child.

6. File for Dismissal

If you have compelling evidence against the CPS allegations, you can file for dismissal with the help of your attorney.

Tips on How to Get a CPS Case Dismissed

Here are some tips on how to get a CPS case dismissed:

#1. Aim for early resolution before going to court

Many CPS cases involve neglect, which demonstrates that the child’s needs are not being met by the parents or guardians. Instead of going to court hearing, such negligence cases can be resolved promptly.

#2. Negotiate a settlement

Abuse and neglect cases can be settled. Organizing a meeting involving you, your client, case investigators, or anyone else involved can help conclude the case before any trials.

#3. Conduct independent investigation

Your client may provide you with all the necessary details. However, your diligent investigation can lead to a quicker case closure. Independently verify data such as medical documentation, psychological evaluations, school records, employment history, and research articles.

#4. Stay updated on changes in federal and state laws

Federal and state laws vary across states in the US. Ensure that you are current with the laws before taking any action in the case. If the charges do not fit the definition of neglect, the court will dismiss the case on the state’s behalf.

#5. Maintain regular contact with your client

Maintaining regular contact with your client is crucial. Get in touch with your client as early as possible and keep them informed about the case’s critical rights. Keeping up-to-date with your client’s living conditions irrespective of the hearing schedule can provide you with useful information about the situation to strengthen the case.

Always be wary of the attorney client relationship.

The Importance of Standing Up to Federal Authorities

While CPS plays a crucial role in protecting child safety, it’s also essential for innocent families to stand up for their rights. False allegations can cause significant distress to both the child and the family. Therefore, understanding how to get a CPS case dismissed is crucial in preserving your family’s well-being and ensuring justice is served.

Conclusion

The process of getting a CPS case dismissed can be challenging and emotionally draining. However, by staying calm, understanding the allegations, and seeking the right legal help, you can navigate the process effectively. Always remember, the goal is to ensure the safety and well-being of the child while preserving the integrity of your family.


0 Comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Send this to a friend